Market Insights

Why Gold Is a Superior Form of Money

Billions of years before governments, banks, money, humans, and the Earth existed…  

Two neutron stars collided and scattered particles of gold into space. Scientists believe those scattered gold particles fused into the Earth’s core as the planet formed. And ancient asteroid impacts brought the precious metal to the surface for humans to eventually discover.

In other words, the gold you can hold in your hand today is quite literally ancient stardust. An out-of-this-world element. 

And since it was first discovered—perhaps glinting in an ancient riverbed—the mesmerizing metal from the heavens has fascinated humankind

Our ancestors recognized gold’s glimmering appeal and its practicality. And around 550 BCE, King Croesus of Lydia minted the world’s first gold coins.  

Since then, competing currencies of all shapes and sizes have come and gone—including livestock, salt, seashells, wheat, feathers, animal pelts, and paper.  

But none surpassed gold. 

Here are 9 reasons why: 

Reason 1: Gold is durable 

Of the 118 elements on the periodic table, only a handful are practical candidates for money.  

The noble gasses are stable, but you can’t make them into coins or carry them in your pocket. The alkali metals, like lithium, sodium, and potassium, are highly reactive and unstable. As are 38 more elements. Some can even burst into flames when exposed to the air.  

The bottom two rows of the periodic chart contain radioactive, highly toxic elements. And of the 30 solid, nontoxic, non-reactive candidates remaining, only five are candidates for money: 

Silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium, and gold.  

Of these five precious metals, platinum, palladium, and rhodium are too rare and too difficult to coin on a large scale. Which leaves silver and gold. Both are rare enough—but not too rare—to find and mine. And both have cost-effective melting points to make physical coins. 

As you may know, silver has been used for money many times throughout history. But it can tarnish and lose its luster. And silver is also far too soft to mint into coins designed to circulate for a long time. 

This leaves gold.  

Gold is virtually indestructible. It won’t tarnish, tear, decay, dissolve, burn, crumble, or rust. And it essentially lasts forever without losing its shape or luster.  

For this reason, nearly all the gold ejected from stars and mined from the earth still exists in some form—including King Croesus’ still-shiny coins from Lydia. 

Reason 2: Gold maintains its value when divided 

Rip paper currency in half, and the torn pieces become worthless. Cut a regular government coin in half and its purchasing power drops to zero. 

Gold, on the other hand, loses no value when divided. 

If gold is priced at $3,200 an ounce, for example, divide that ounce in half and you now have two half ounces worth $1,600 each. Cut them in half again and each quarter ounce is worth $800.  

Reason 3: Gold is uniform and unchanging 

An ounce of pure gold in your hand today is identical to an ounce of pure gold mined in ancient Lydia.  

This unchanging nature makes gold ideal as a standardized, uniform unit of exchange regardless of place and time.  

Reason 4: Gold’s value-to-size ratio makes it easy to transport and store a lot of wealth in a small space 

$10,000 of gold at current prices, for example, weighs a mere three ounces. $100,000 in gold bullion weighs about 1.8 pounds.  

And some gold bullion is so rare a single coin could be worth many hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars. 

The 1933 Double Eagle, for example, is so rare that experts estimate only 15 coins remain. One of the 15 sold for a whopping $18.9 million at a 2021 auction.  

Reason 5: Gold is easy to buy and sell 

You can buy or sell physical gold in any form with ease.  

Spot prices make it simple to convert gold to dollars on the open market at its current value. And in most cases, the transaction only takes a few minutes. 

Reason 6: The world’s gold supply is finite 

While the total amount of physical gold available in the world is unknown, the supply is fixed

In fact, the US Geological Survey estimates that all of the gold discovered thus far (an estimated 200,000 tons) would fit into a cube about the size of a swimming pool.

This gives gold value through simple supply and demand. 

By contrast, one of the main causes for the failure of fiat (government-issued and not backed with a real asset) currencies is the relatively cheap cost for governments to print as many bills as they like “out of thin air.” 

However…  

Reason 7: Governments can’t print gold 

Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, US dollars were issued as gold certificates.  

Each bill’s face value was worth a fixed amount of gold. And you could redeem the bill at any US bank to receive your gold on demand.  

But that ended in 1971 when President Nixon severed the US dollar’s link to gold. Dollars were then issued by decree or “fiat”—backed not by gold but by the full faith and credit of the United States government. 

This new fiat currency system gave central banks the power to create new dollars at any time for any reason. And this, critics argue, is the dollar’s weakness.  

Because the more the US Treasury expands the money supply, in simplest terms, the more inflation rises because the dollar loses purchasing power through simple dilution.  

Meanwhile, gold is a physical commodity, and its supply is difficult to expand. This has made gold historically a trusted hedge against inflation over the long term. 

And if the federal government continues its deficit spending spree…and if gold behaves as it generally has…we could see it not only hold its value but also grow in value over time because…  

Reason 8: Gold is a reliable store of value 

To maintain its financial utility in society, the value of any money must remain relatively stable over long periods.  

Since the “Nixon Shock” of 1971, the US dollar has lost around 88% of its purchasing power

But in those same 52 years, gold has gained nearly 9,000% in value relative to the falling US dollar. 

In other words, gold hasn’t been devalued by overprinting.  

But that’s not all.  

Gold has not only outperformed the US dollar over time…  

Reason 9: Gold has outperformed ALL major fiat currencies since 1900. 

As you can see, despite consistent loss of value across the board for fiat currencies, gold has maintained its purchasing power. 

And this is one of the reasons central banks across the world not only own gold but also buy it in mass quantities at an accelerated rate to hold as a safe-haven asset. 

Will America return to the Gold Standard? 

Many financial experts, including Steve Forbes, urge the US to return to the Gold Standard.  

According to Forbes, “…the existence of a gold standard would have prevented the economic disasters of this century, including our present woes. For starters. you don’t get inflation with a gold-based monetary system.” 

Bettina Bien Greaves of the Foundation for Economic Education agrees and writes, “under a gold standard…the purchasing power per unit of gold would be more stable than under an unpredictable paper currency standard.” 

And economist Ludwig von Mises said, “The gold standard has one tremendous virtue: the quantity of the money supply, under the gold standard, is independent of the policies of governments and political parties. This is its advantage. It is a form of protection against spendthrift governments.” 

Forbes, Greaves, and von Mises understand what King Croesus of Lydia and countless others have known for thousands of years: 

Gold—the precious metal from the stars—is the superior form of money. 

Please don’t hesitate to reach out to us with any questions you may have. 

May you be safe and well during these uncertain times.   

Todd Sawyer, Director of Client Education  
Colonial Metals Group